This recipe is a family favorites. Sadly, I stopped making these a few years ago because of my son’s allergy to peanuts.
But this year Chris suggested making them using Peabutter (the alternative we use to peanut butter.) Yes! Why hadn’t I thought of that sooner? They turned out great! I can’t even taste the difference. I guess a bunch of sugar can mask anything 🙂
Here’s my assistance showing you with a very serious face our “No Nut” peabutter:
And while Mommy stirred the ingredients on the stove, the little elves did some painting:
Our Lesson: Just like all the different colored marshmallows, we are all different and all special. God made each of us unique and we are thankful for our differences 🙂
Peanut Butter Squares
1/4 cup butter
1 pkg butterscotch chips
1/2 cup peanut butter (or in our case PEAbutter)
3 cups marshmallows
Melt butter, peanut butter and chips. Remove from heat. Add marshmallows. Pour into greased 9X9 pan.


I love Jesus, my guy Chris + our four. We seek joy. Homeschool. Adventure together. Mess up and start again.
I love the lesson for your kiddos too!
Oh Sara these are my favorite treats ever! We make a huge pan and freeze them… My gramma used to make them for us all the time 🙂 Thanks for reminding me of the alternative! I am glad it still tastes the same…
I love the lesson for your kiddos too!